Claim & evidence

Dan Richards: an archaic GLI3 variant gave mice extra digits

Contradicted by the cited source

The paper explicitly reports no limb or digit abnormalities in mice carrying this variant. It reports other skeletal changes, but not extra digits. Richards’s account conflicts with that result.

The claim in context

The archaic human GLI3 R1537C variant and equivalent R1540C mouse model in Agata and colleagues’ 2023 study.

Richards attributes extra digits to the variant-bearing mice. This assessment checks that specific result against the paper.

What the sources say

Where it was discussed

1 episode discussing this claim.

Related discussions

Related arguments and comparisons; these do not repeat the same claim about the same objects.

What this assessment doesn’t establish

  • The verdict concerns this specific experiment, not every GLI3-related condition.
  • Other skeletal changes were reported; the negative digit result does not erase them.
  • A mouse experiment cannot identify the genotype or ancestry of ancient human remains.